Using Democracy to Destroy Democracy

Bakri’s remark is interesting precisely because it removes the comforting assumption of reciprocity. A western liberal hears “freedom of speech” and thinks of a principle. Someone like Bakri hears “freedom of speech” and thinks of a vulnerability in the enemy.

— Hector Herrera
“We Will Use Your Democracy to Destroy Your Democracy” (Opens new window)

From the same essay:

Years before ISIS existed, the Islamist cleric Omar Bakri Mohammed reportedly told journalist Patrick Goodenough something that seems to be willfully ignored by the vast majority of people in the West:

“We will use your democracy to destroy your democracy.”

In one sentence, Bakri identified the vulnerability at the heart of a free society.

——

The western liberal assumes that we are all playing the same game, disagreeing perhaps viciously over policy, interpretation and the application of the rules, but accepting the basic constitutional framework within which our opponents retain their rights if we win.

The revolutionary may have no such intention. He can believe in our freedom instrumentally. He can use free speech without believing that free speech should survive his victory. He can use freedom of religion while believing apostasy should eventually be punished. He can use democratic elections while regarding democracy merely as the vehicle by which democracy can be brought to an end.

This is not a new problem. What may be new is our reluctance—or hubris—to admit that anyone, especially our enemies, thinks this way.

——

If a movement tells you openly that it intends to use your freedoms to destroy the system that guarantees them, are you required to pretend that this intention is irrelevant, particularly when the people advancing that project are guests, students or permanent residents?

Should a free society extend the full protections of free speech and political liberty to non-citizens it has admitted who would use those freedoms to destroy the system that protects them?

—–

That tension is hardly new. Thomas Jefferson put it this way in 1810:

“A strict observance of the written laws is doubtless one of the high duties of a good citizen: but it is not the highest. The laws of necessity, of self-preservation, of saving our country when in danger, are of higher obligation. To lose our country by a scrupulous adherence to written law, would be to lose the law itself, with life, liberty, property & all those who are enjoying them with us; thus absurdly sacrificing the end to the means.”

—–

There must therefore be some point at which preserving the system takes priority over the ordinary rules of the system.

—-

What if your adversary understands himself to be participating in a centuries-long struggle against you while we insist on understanding him solely as another voice in the marketplace of ideas?

At what point does our tolerance cease being strength and become denial?




As censorship increases also consider using email and text messages to send links.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *